advertisement


red line SuperKids Software Review - The Parent's and Teacher's Guide to Childrens' Software
free newsletter! spacer tell a friend! spacer contests
spacer
software
  reviews
  bestseller list
  price survey
  what's new
  product support
  search
spacer
educational tools
  math worksheets
  vocabulary builders
  hangman
  iPhone/iPad apps
  logic games
  brain food
spacer
educational insights

feature articles
spacer
marketplace
  iPhone/iPad apps
  reading corner
  movie corner
spacer
SuperKids home
  about SuperKids
  advertise!
  humor
  links
  help
spacer
  * * *

Promotions




  * * *




  * * *

spacer all reviews > > > interactive book software

The Book of Lulu

Organa

Ages 5 and up

Rating Scale
5 = great,    1 = poor
Educational Value
3.0
Kid Appeal
2.5
Ease of Use
4.0

The Book of Lulu arrow indentSystem Requirements

arrow indentPC / Mac Price Survey

arrow indentProduct Support

The tale of a charming storybook princess named Lulu who embarks on an adventure with the space-robot Mnemo, The Book of Lulu closely mimics the physical and cognitive experience of reading a book—and then goes beyond. The program opens with a graphic of an open book with cream-colored pages; clicking the corner of the page causes it to turn with a satisfying fwipp. Clicking on the illustrations and on the text produces a variety of special effects: some animations go “full screen” and act out the plot; and others simply add whimsical detail within the physical confines of the book. Characters literally step out of the pages and push the plot along, raising the question of who is really in control of the story: The writer? The reader? The characters themselves?

The Book of Lulu does not offer multiple endings or mysteries or hidden treasure as motivation for the reader to finish or to revisit it. It relies, as a good children’s book should, on an engaging plot, appealing characters, and beautiful graphics to inspire multiple readings. That said, children are not likely to return to it as they would a book—they still see it as a game, and a game you can’t win is not a good game.

Educational Value

Certainly, younger readers can get practice reading along with the narrator. The animation occasionally precludes asking, “What do you think happens next?” but mostly it offers a beautiful supplement to the text. There remain dozens of questions to be asked, both concrete and philosophical—but as with any book a child reads, it is up to the adult to ask most of those questions. Insofar as any book is an educational tool, The Book of Lulu is, too; but its main purpose is to entertain.

Kid Appeal

Haunting background music perfectly complements the “illustrations”, which evoke 19th century pen-and-ink drawings and create a nostalgic, almost wistful mood—the reader really feels as if she is reading an old storybook. The twist at the end, as mentioned earlier, raises all kinds of philosophical questions. It is probably for these reasons that The Book of Lulu has won its various awards for excellence.

However, most of our testers’ (ages six to eleven) reactions were lukewarm at best. Kids said they wouldn’t play it more than once or twice, even though it was “pretty interesting”, citing the lack of a “goal” or multiple endings as a major flaw in the program. The language is fairly sophisticated for children close to the lower end of the recommended age range, and the plot moves too slowly in the first half to hold the attention of younger children and those with short attention spans.

Ease of Use / Install

Installation of The Book of Lulu is an easy three-step process: register by entering name and company; choose a directory in which to save the program; decide whether you need to download the required version of Quicktime (4.1). Et voila.

Turning pages and activating the animations is simple and intuitive, but users need to read the instructions initially in order to locate and identify the various icons necessary to activate the narration or occasionally to return from the animations to the text.

Best for... / Bottom-Line

The Book of Lulu has been hailed by many reviewers as a “classic”, and indeed it does have the makings of a classic book--so much so that one might almost just as well sit down and read a real book with a child. It is best for children who can hold onto the thread of a plot despite the distraction of searching for cool animations; however, the tester who paid no attention to the plot enjoyed it the most. Regardless of how much a child enjoys it, he or she is unlikely to “read” the book all the way through more than twice or thrice.

See SuperKids' comparisons with other interactive book software titles, and the Buyers Guide for current market prices of the PC and Mac versions.

System Requirements
PC: Windows 98/XP, CD-ROM or Windows DVD I .

Mac: Mac OS, CD-ROM .
return to top of page



Go to: About SuperKids Educational Software Review
Questions or comments regarding this site? webmaster@superkids.com
Copyright © 1998-2016 Knowledge Share LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy